Man stabbed driver to death with son in car after walking into busy road

Pedestrian Alexander Layton denies murdering “complete stranger” James Stokoe following a disagreement in the street in May 2020
James Stokoe (Cleveland Police/PA)
PA Media
Tom Wilkinson17 November 2021

A pedestrian stabbed a driver to death in front of his young son after the motorist performed an emergency stop to avoid running him over and then angrily shouted at him, a court heard.

Alexander Layton “acted in a calm, considered but brutal manner” when he stabbed James Stokoe, a 40-year-old married father, in his BMW in Thornaby, Teesside in May 2020, jurors were told.

Mr Stokoe had taken his four-year-old to see his grandparents and the boy was strapped in a car seat at the time of the attack, the court heard.

Layton, 34, from Shackleton Close, Thornaby, is on trial at Teesside Crown Court. He denies murder and possessing an offensive weapon, and will claim self-defence.

Mr Layton pulled out a large carving knife and repeatedly stabbed Mr Stokoe, who bled to death within minutes

Peter Makepeace

Peter Makepeace QC, prosecuting, said Layton had got off a bus after a trip to a food bank when he crossed a busy main road, causing Mr Stokoe to brake sharply.

Mr Makepeace told the jury: “It was witnessed by several passers-by.

“It was a verbal dispute and it followed a near miss after this defendant went on to Trenchard Avenue, seemingly without looking or paying attention, into the path of Mr Stokoe’s BMW.

“During the verbal exchange, Mr Layton pulled out a large carving knife and repeatedly stabbed Mr Stokoe, who bled to death within minutes.”

In the hours immediately before the attack, Layton had threatened to murder a man who owed him money, and his family, the court heard.

Earlier still on the same day he had texted a contact to share conspiracy theories about 5G masts, Mr Makepeace said.

In the early hours of that day, he also emailed Stockton Borough Council to say he needed help with food and fuel and was feeling suicidal.

After a trip to Stockton to pick up food from a church, at around 2pm his path crossed that of Mr Stokoe, “a complete stranger” who worked at a local garage, Mr Makepeace said.

Mr Stokoe must have been shocked, indeed angry, about the near miss that had occurred. That might have been compounded by the fact (his son) was in a booster seat in the back of the car

Peter Makepeace

CCTV and dashcam footage showed Layton getting off a bus, almost being run over, then stabbing Mr Stokoe four times.

The driver had pulled over to remonstrate with Layton, getting out of his car to shout at him, then getting back in the car and pulling over at the side of the road close to the pedestrian.

Witnesses said Mr Stokoe shouted: “Are you f****** daft? I nearly knocked you over. I’ve got a kid in this car.”

Layton, on the other side of the road at this point, apparently shouted back: “Are you talking to me? F*** off. I’m here. Come over. Come on.”

Mr Makepeace said: “Clearly Mr Stokoe must have been shocked, indeed angry, about the near miss that had occurred.

“That might have been compounded by the fact (his son) was in a booster seat in the back of the car.”

But, the prosecution said, that did not explain or excuse Layton’s actions as he stabbed Mr Stokoe three times in the leg and once in the arm, severing his femoral artery.

The emergency services were called and an air ambulance landed at the scene but he died in the back of an ambulance.

His wife, a lab technician at Durham University even called him to warn that traffic was bad in the area due to the ongoing incident, the court heard.

Layton fled the scene, dumped the carving knife, which has not been found, and went camping in Great Ayton, before he was arrested the next night in a pizza shop.

Mr Makepeace said Layton told police after he was arrested it had been an “accident”, he had not meant to do it and “it only went into his leg”.

The prosecution said he gave detectives a statement claiming he was acting in self-defence and was scared.

Mr Makepeace said: “Mr Layton acted in a calm, considered but brutal manner.”

The trial continues.

Create a FREE account to continue reading

eros

Registration is a free and easy way to support our journalism.

Join our community where you can: comment on stories; sign up to newsletters; enter competitions and access content on our app.

Your email address

Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number

You must be at least 18 years old to create an account

* Required fields

Already have an account? SIGN IN

By clicking Create Account you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use , Cookie policy and Privacy policy .

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in